The Visual Critic™
Learn some do’s and don’ts by watching these video clips and following the observations of Tom Mucciolo as he plays the role of The VISUAL CRITIC™.
Click Image to Play/Pause
On this page you will see PUBLIC performances, linked to content posted on YouTube or YouTube-like sites that host the original video content.
From a copyright perspective, the intent of these reviews is for educational purposes only. There is no recommendation, implied endorsement or promotion of the artists, speakers, or presenters.
Some of the clips are narrated observations, while other clips are referenced and reviewed in a frame-based visual analysis.
Choose from the following clips:
-
Observing Body Language - Charlie Rose Interview - Bill Gates
-
Music Video - Coldplay - Viva la Vida
-
Broadway Musical - Pippin - Magic to Do
-
CEO of Cybertech - Aniket Warty
Observing Body Language (narrated by Tom Mucciolo)
Bill Gates is interviewed by Charlie Rose. Excerpts from the segment are analyzed from a body language perspective. Challenges and opportunities are discussed related to Conversational-izing, Virtual Space and Timelines.
A visual analysis of Coldplay’s Viva la Vida
Try it now by hovering over this time code (0:00
as you hold mouse over time code ) to see an example appear on the right.

“Sweep the streets …”
), “listen as the crowd would sing” (0:51

“listen as the crowd would sing”
), and, “long live the king” (0:55

“long live the king”
) all demonstrate the closing-off of the vocal tones by finishing the words completely. In the absence of this skill, a person may accidentally “clip” the sentences by rushing into the beginning of the next phrase before closing the prior one.

“roll the dice”
) and “I held the key” (0:58

“I held the key”
), allowing the viewer to match the lyrics to a visual depiction of the story. This skill of using virtual space to let the hands describe thoughts, adds a third dimension to the content bringing it to life. His uses virtual space again when he mimics physical “structures” sung in the verse “my castles stand on pillars of salt and pillars of sand” (1:05

“my castles stand …”
).

puppet-like dance moves
), separating his hand movements from his body actions while setting up a visual ANCHOR that shows-up a half-minute later with the actual lyric “just a puppet on a lonely string” (2:14

“just a puppet on a lonely string” ).

“I hear Jerusalem bells …” ), but even more prominent during the 20-second sequence, from 2:45 to 3:05, beginning with “That’s when I ruled the world”, where we see an all inclusive wide embrace of the entire “world” (2:45

“That’s when I ruled the world” ) suddenly become a demonstrative targeted offer directly to the camera (2:47

Martin makes a direct “offer” ) or really to us, as viewers.

protective fig-leaf position ) in opposition to Martin’s open expression (3:58

open body position ). When the front of the body is revealed (open), self-confidence appears, empowering the person. This leadership quality is consistent with Martin as he claims to be someone who “ruled the world”.
Overall, I think that this music video demonstrates a number of performance elements that clearly can be used in presentation settings. You can learn a lot from musical performances — as long as you don’t try to sing your way through the content!
A visual analysis of the Broadway Cast from Pippin
Following the video clip below, comments are identified parenthetically by time code, which you can move your mouse over (hover) to view the specific part of the nearly four-minute clip. Try it now by hovering over this time code (0:00
as you hold mouse over time code ) to see an example appear on the right.

framing the face ). He makes his first offer on the phrase, “we’ve got magic to do” (0:58

making a direct “offer” ) as he opens his hands to the audience. The opening of the palms signifies approachability and friendliness on the part of the person.

“we’ve got parts to perform” ), the sets of floating hands on each side of Ben Vereen (circled on the image) open-up to demonstrate “perform”, and then cross over one another on “hearts to warm” (1:07

“hearts to warm” ), just as his hands naturally embrace his heart. The gestures perfectly match the words, visually describing the concepts, differentiating “perform” (openly to the audience) from “warm” (closer to the heart). This is not to suggest that you mime every phrase in your presentation; instead, you should consider linking gestures to specific concepts where you think greater impact is needed.

a fluid gesture, inviting the crowd ). Just as the camera-angle changes, notice how his right hand smoothly beckons, as if enticing the audience to get closer to the action. This movement requires the hand muscles to be extremely relaxed, yet the action requires a high degree of concentration to generate the snake-like, hypnotic movement. This is similar to Michael Jackson’s famous moonwalk, where each small move of the body (toe-to-heel) must be thought-out to create the impression of gliding backwards, as if floating.

“intrigue, plots to bring disaster” ), “humor” (1:27

“humor, handled by a master” ); or, even without words, as in Ben Vereen’s two-handed “frozen” gesture to reveal the two women (1:29

“frozen” gesture for reference ); and then again, with a character expressing “illusion” (1:37

“illusion, fantasy to study” ) while freezing the hands. Gestures that freeze will have more power, especially when making an important point. When the body language of the gesture stops moving, the spoken language of the voice gets more focus. If you keep moving your hands constantly when speaking, you have two languages happening at the same time, which may become distracting. Gestures can overlap speech, but not continue simultaneously.

entire cast using gestures ) as they use expressive gestures, both with the body and with the hands. See how many words you can link to specific actions of the performers, such as a repeat of the “hearts to warm” gesture (1:59

“hearts to warm” gesture ).

open body, highly confident ) is a perfect display of self-confidence. By revealing the middle of the body (the soft, vulnerable part) the message is clearly out in the open, unprotected, totally transparent. Although the hands of the dancers (2:46

open body, highly confident ) are overly exaggerated for dramatic effect, there is value in open body expressions. This action repeats again (3:20

open body, approaching ) and is heightened as the group moves toward the audience.

making a grand gesture (offer) ), with heads up and palms out. But as Ben Vereen takes the final bow (3:51

open palms continue the offer ), his palms face down to direct the group to bow their heads, but notice how their palms still remain open, to continue making the offer to the audience, welcoming them into their world.
The late Bob Fosse was a master of physical expression, and a lot can be gleaned from theatrical performances. As you watch this clip, you can see the value of gestures, as a means of adding a third dimension to the content, to bring the story to life.
A visual analysis of Aniket Warty, CEO of Cybertech
In this short 2-minute clip from March, 2008, posted in the public domain, Mr. Warty uses a number of directed hand gestures to emphasize certain points. His continuity is mildly challenged because of the consecutive interpretation (translation), forcing him to pause after a few sentences so that the translation can occur. Regardless of that, Mr. Warty seamlessly adds value in his delivery to engage his audience.
Following the video clip below, comments are identified parenthetically by time code, which you can move your mouse over (hover) to view the specific part of the nearly four-minute clip. Try it now by hovering over this time code (0:00
as you hold mouse over time code ) to see an example appear on the right.
The video clip actually starts with a blue-screen banner, with Aniket Warty’s first name misspelled (Ankeit), but thereafter the spelling is correct throughout the clip. The scene opens into a crowded conference room, with a lectern (podium) positioned to one side. An interpreter is on the opposite side of the room.
After his introduction, Mr. Warty moves behind the lectern, and steps up onto a small platform which allows more of his upper body to be visible, giving him the opportunity to use gestures more naturally. If you have speakers who must stand behind a lectern, consider placing a small riser (step), to give the speaker greater visibility. This helps those of shorter stature, male or female.

“…with open arms” ); and, then he immediately reaches out to the group on “…as you have welcomed us…” (0:30

“…as you have welcomed us” ). Usually, gestures are naturally prompted by certain parts of speech, such as pronouns (you, us, we, this, that) and adverbs (here, there). Mr. Warty matches his words to his actions effectively.

eyes “give focus” to interpreter ). Anyone still looking at Mr. Warty will notice his eye contact is directed to the interpreter, coupled with his body leaning forward, indicating that the focus has moved away from him.

weight shifts, direct eye contact ). The only negative moment in this sequence is when he looks down (0:48

breaks eye contact ), thus breaking the eye contact (connection) with the audience. Yet, with body movement and eye contact actions established (used at least once), he now only needs to use his eyes to give the focus back to the interpreter (0:55

gives focus to interpreter ). Audiences grow to understand your body language moves, especially if you use those actions consistently.

“…is a team” ). This incongruity of having the hands open (approachable) and the eyes diverted (looking down) reduces his confidence in the “team” concept. It is critical to make your key points with actions that match one another, such as hand gestures and eye contact.

“…motivated professionals” ). By using his hands to place items in the air to momentarily reference information, he helps the audience visualize the content. Mr. Warty also uses virtual space to name different countries (1:24

gestures to include countries ).

holding down, or sheltering? ). When the palms face down, the indication may be interpreted as trying to hold the emotions down; however, in this context it appears to be more of a sheltering move, as in gathering everyone under the same umbrella, so to speak. This is supported by Mr. Warty’s very next phrase “…achieving a common goal” (1:31

“…a common goal” ), where he uses virtual space to shape the concept by opening his hands and then moving them in unison toward the audience, as if sharing the gift of a common goal.

“…success” directed to side ), because he offers that with a gesture to the interpreter rather than the audience. If Mr. Warty had targeted the word “success” directly to the group, using a reaching out (open palms) gesture, he would have achieved a greater impact.

gives focus by leaning-in ); and then, as he feels the translation ending, he takes focus by shifting his weight away from the interpreter (1:50

takes focus by leaning-away ).

“…thank you” (open) ), but he breaks the eye contact on the phrase “…for welcoming us…” (1:57

“…for welcoming us” (down) ), by looking down. This momentary diversion only slightly reduces the impact of the appreciation.

open gesture with smile ), which continues as he leaves the speaking area (2:04

walks off smiling ), adding a measure of happiness to the overall speech. Although there were a few minor inconsistencies, I think that Mr. Warty demonstrates effective speaking skills by matching body language with vocal expression. In addition, his fluid transitions in the exchanges with the interpreter, allow the talk to progress smoothly.
